Hi, guys. I wanted to run an idea past you for a fun podcast segment--"Your Game Sucks!" The idea is to take an indie game and explain (in a humorous way) why it sucks. It may sound mean, but the idea is actually to win it some publicity, and the criticisms will be over-the-top. Think of it more as teasing or satire than genuine insults or criticism.
Anyway, I know Chip has been covering a lot of games in his amazing "Three for the Road" series, so let me know what you'd like me to do. I'm thinking I could cover three per episode for Armchair Arcade Radio. (I'd love to make this a joint segment, but still working on that). I also think it'd be hilarious to get some of the designers in the segment, too, reacting (in character, of course) to the ridiculousness.
So, in general what do you think of the idea, and secondly, what games would you like to see bashed? Remember that this is current indie games, not big-budget stuff or abandonware.
The idea is great, but probably won't work with every indie title out there - the games to be chosen should have some qualities that are prone to be made fun of (a bit), while still being great in their entirety.
So which indies I would suggest? Well, for example I think What Linus Bruckman Sees When His Eyes Are Closed would be perfect here. Also Infinity String, "!", Earl Bobby trilogy, and the Barn Runner series.
Oh, and anything from thecatamites - from Space Funeral to Astonishing Captain Skull.
And I won't lie I'd be very happy if my own game Snakes of Avalon got such treatment.